Mystery Tackle Box Reviews

Based on 103 customer reviews from our shopper community, Mystery Tackle Box's overall rating is 4.50 out of 5 stars and 87% of reviewers recommend this brand, which indicates that most consumers are generally satisfied with their purchases.

4.5

103 Reviews

Overall Rating

5 Stars

85

4 Stars

4

3 Stars

1

2 Stars

7

1 Star

6

Good Value

0.0

Price & Quality

0.0

Shipping & Delivery

0.0

Customer Service

0.0

Return Policy

0.0

All Reviews (103)
user icon
Joseph.Morrison
May 09, 2023
"Great Gift"
My nephew loves to get his box every month. He loves the tackle and all the information that he receives.
user icon
lazyduck569
April 23, 2023
"Great deal"
Great deal, I get every other month. Have been satisfied with all boxes I have received.
Fast shipping,great products.
Great gift idea for anglers of all ages .
user icon
Vivan.Douglas
March 29, 2023
"Fun in A box"
The lures are for the current times of the year that you get the box it's hassle free a great surprise every month lures are very good well worth the money
user icon
chaaalie
March 29, 2023
"Good quality products great customer service"
Good quality products, when they did have an issue they corrected it immediately once before I even noticed. Highly recommend this great gift idea
user icon
ClaireBurton
March 29, 2023
"Always sends good baits and I always…"
Always sends good baits and I always catch something good with the baits. Best box ever
user icon
JeanetteBowman
March 25, 2023
"Every month my grandson is delighted"
Every month my grandson is delighted! Too many bait plastic worms though!! Don’t need as many as are sent each month!!
user icon
Pat_28
March 25, 2023
"The affordability and the guessing game…"
The affordability and the guessing game of what I’ll get next I have used a few of my new lures and they definitely work well the top water explosion is amazing I will always recommend mystery Taclebox to friends and family thank you guys
user icon
tinypeacock844
March 16, 2023
"BEYOND DISAPPOINTED"
Beyond disappointed. Bought the Elite Box 6 month subscription for my husband and canceled after the second disappointing box. He received the third of the six today and it was EXACTLY the same stuff they sent last month. They send out an email with a sneak peak of your box and there was not a single one of those items in the box. Husband says it's worth about $10.
user icon
megphalen
March 14, 2023
"High quality well made fishing lures at…who wouldn't change anything that they have done cuz they are top quality lures"
High quality well made fishing lures at a reasonable price. Started my subscription in August of 2022 for my birthday and I'm trying to convince my wife to carry it over to 2023 and buy the bigger box way cool stuff and my kids love to use it also
user icon
PhyllisHanson
March 03, 2023
"The boxes are filled with great tackle"
The boxes are filled with great tackle, stickers, and information on how to use everything.
user icon
ticklishkoala745
March 01, 2023
"I love getting different Baites every…"
I love getting different Baites every month. Love the fact that she could change species anytime
user icon
blackwolf108
March 01, 2023
"the lake I live on.…"
The lake I live on is not ready to fish, to cold and not frozen over. The lures i get from MTB fit my lake and targets the fish I fish for. I have caught nice fish with the stuff I get from them. every lure has caught at least one fish.
user icon
Georgeacund
February 23, 2023
"The package always been on time and…"
The package always been on time and delivered to the right destination and good quality lures.
user icon
sadrabbit744
February 23, 2023
"I’ve purchased the monthly box for a…"
I’ve purchased the monthly box for a full year and it’s been an absolute dream. Every box has gotten me more confident in preparing for the summer fishing trips and competitions. The variety per box takes all the hassle out of selecting new tackles. 10/10 will continue to buy
user icon
michele.askew
February 22, 2023
"I have been signed up a few months now…"
I have been signed up a few months now have gotten pretty solid stuff every single month box’s always show up on the 10th never have been a day later. Had a payment issue a while back and they sent me a free lure plus my box to fix the situation. I also was somehow signed up for Karl’s and I completely forgot to cancel after the free trial and was greatly refunded immediately without any hesitation 10/10 service with mtb!

View More Reviews

What do you want to know about this brand?
review icon

Customer Reviews

a icon

Ask a Question

cookies tips
Welcome to WorthEPenny.com! We use cookies to better understand your preferences, optimize our website and services, enhance user experiences, personalize content and ads, and provide social media and other third-party features. If you want to learn more about cookies and why we use them, visit our Cookie Policy page.